Wednesday, April 14, 2021
  • Setup menu at Appearance » Menus and assign menu to Top Bar Navigation
Advertisement
  • AI Development
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Machine Learning
    • Neural Networks
    • Learn to Code
  • Data
    • Blockchain
    • Big Data
    • Data Science
  • IT Security
    • Internet Privacy
    • Internet Security
  • Marketing
    • Digital Marketing
    • Marketing Technology
  • Technology Companies
  • Crypto News
No Result
View All Result
NikolaNews
  • AI Development
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Machine Learning
    • Neural Networks
    • Learn to Code
  • Data
    • Blockchain
    • Big Data
    • Data Science
  • IT Security
    • Internet Privacy
    • Internet Security
  • Marketing
    • Digital Marketing
    • Marketing Technology
  • Technology Companies
  • Crypto News
No Result
View All Result
NikolaNews
No Result
View All Result
Home Internet Security

Clampdown on US border device searches not such a big deal

November 17, 2019
in Internet Security
Clampdown on US border device searches not such a big deal
585
SHARES
3.3k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter



This week’s US federal court decision that travellers’ phones and laptops cannot be searched arbitrarily isn’t necessarily as big a win for privacy advocates as it might first appear. Conditions apply.

You might also like

Cybersecurity: Victims are spotting cyber attacks much more quickly – but there’s a catch

Samsung’s new Galaxy Quantum 2 uses quantum cryptography to secure apps

Brave browser disables Google’s FLoC tracking system

The case, heard in the the District Court in Boston, Massachusetts by Justice Denise J Casper, concerns 11 travellers who had their mobile devices searched without warrant by US Customs and Border Patrol (CBP) and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). In some cases, the devices being searched were confiscated.

One was a lawful permanent resident, the rest were US citizens. Such searches, they argued, breached their rights under the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution against unreasonable searches and seizures.

Casper agreed, but it’s more complicated than that.

At the heart of this case is a legal doctrine called the border search exception, which allows searches and seizures at international borders without a warrant or probable cause. All searches at borders are deemed to be reasonable.

According to Professor Bobby Chesney at the University of Texas School of Law, this doctrine has been around “forever”. There are “plainly legitimate real good-faith reasons to try to detect contraband”, he says, and that’s “a very worthy government goal”.

“The underlying justification is the general plenary [unqualified or absolute] control of the federal government over the border, and especially the interest in protecting the integrity of the nation and its laws, including especially inspection for contraband or things that shouldn’t come in,” Chesney said on the National Security Law Podcast on Wednesday.

“In a purely tangible materials world there is only so much there’s going to be with you that’s coming in, and there’s only so much invasion of your privacy that’s entailed necessarily in searching for contraband,” he said.

“The thing that’s changed is the classic story of technological disruption. So now we carry our lives with us on our phones and laptops, and most of us most of the time if we’re doing international travel are gonna more or less have little or no choice but to take that stuff with us.”

Judge Casper, at the district court level, has effectively agreed that the world of information that’s suddenly exposed by what Chesney called “device deep-dives” had a “wildly different amount of privacy cost”.

As Casper wrote in her summary judgement: “Even a basic search allows for both a general perusal and a particularised search of a traveler’s personal data, images, files, and even sensitive information.”

In that context, a “basic search” is a search of the device using its native operating system — logging in and having a look around.

An “advanced search”, according to Chesney, is “where you use some external equipment, wirelessly or by wire, to more thoroughly and comprehensively [explore and] perhaps even copy [data]”. A device may be seized for days and examined using digital forensic tools.

But Casper hasn’t said that CBP and ICE need a warrant. She’s said they they need “reasonable articulable suspicion”.

“Moreover, the reasonable suspicion that is required for the currently defined basic search and advanced search is a showing of specific and articulable facts, considered with reasonable inferences drawn from those facts, that the electronic devices contains contraband,” she wrote.

Chesney says the judgment’s requirements, which fall short of needing a warrant, are “not as big a victory for the privacy side”.

“This would be a dramatically bigger deal if they’re saying ‘Nope, go get a warrant based on probable cause shown in order to search these devices’,” he said.

“On the other hand I think this contraband element is potentially a big deal. Potentially.”

Yes, the judgment talks about contraband specifically.

“Well that narrows it. It’s very interesting to think about that way,” Chesney said.

Or as the colleague Professor Steve Vladeck put it: “It’s not just reasonable suspicion of something sketchy … so some of it depends on how it gets operationalised in practice.”

Vladeck said it’s “long past time” for the US Supreme Court to revisit the question of border searches. The last big case was United States v. Martinez-Fuerte in 1976, which allowed CBP to set up permanent or fixed checkpoints on public highways leading to or away from the Mexican border.

“Meshing the border search doctrine with the sort of shifts in the Supreme Court’s approach to technology is long overdue,” he said.

For his part, Chesney would like to see Congress get involved.

“We do this in spades with all the FISA [Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act] stuff, the 702 stuff, and things like ‘well let’s require by statute certain types of record-keeping and reporting so we could learn what really happen’,” he said.

Chesney proposed statutory requirements for “writing down of the predicates that constitute these specific and articulable facts that the device contains contraband”, collecting data over, say, two years and reporting to the judiciary committees or the like.

“That’s a crazy idea. I mean obviously it’s never gonna happen,” he said.

“Yet we seem so quick to be willing to get Congress involved with legislation including oversight legislation on the intelligence collection side. But for these law enforcement activities we just sort of wait for courts to develop this idea or that idea.”

So, Casper’s decision is about points of entry to the US only, and about contraband only. It still doesn’t mean a warrant is required.

And there’s still a “national security” exemption.

And there’s still no reassurance for the 96% of the world’s population who are not US citizens or permanent residents, because none of the plaintiffs in this case were “aliens”.

As this typical explainer from Victor Malca Law describes, non-citizens do have some constitutional rights in the US, but there are “certain exceptions”.

“The constitution protects the rights of non-citizens within the US territory. You are technically outside US territory when you are still at the border or the airport. Thus, these constitutional rights don’t apply,” they write.

“Non-citizens are protected from unreasonable searches when they are inside the US. This means that searches and confiscations at the border are legal.”

Related Coverage

US Court rules travellers’ phones and laptops cannot be searched arbitrarily

Any searches conducted at the US border without reasonable suspicion will now be a violation of the Fourth Amendment.

Google employees protest: ‘Don’t bid for border control cloud contract’

Google workers are demanding the company doesn’t bid for an immigration contract, even though it already supplies the agency with cloud services.

NSA surveillance of foreign nationals surges

Domestic communications record slurping is reducing, but global spying is on the uptick.

Google’s plan to collect health data on millions of Americans faces federal inquiry

Google defends its Project Nightingale deal with Ascension, which involves access to detailed patient records.

Credit: Zdnet

Previous Post

Can the planet really afford the exorbitant power demands of machine learning? | John Naughton | Opinion

Next Post

Goldman Sachs Must Amend AI Bias to Regain Apple Card User Trust

Related Posts

Cybersecurity: Victims are spotting cyber attacks much more quickly – but there’s a catch
Internet Security

Cybersecurity: Victims are spotting cyber attacks much more quickly – but there’s a catch

April 14, 2021
Samsung’s new Galaxy Quantum 2 uses quantum cryptography to secure apps
Internet Security

Samsung’s new Galaxy Quantum 2 uses quantum cryptography to secure apps

April 14, 2021
Brave browser disables Google’s FLoC tracking system
Internet Security

Brave browser disables Google’s FLoC tracking system

April 13, 2021
These new vulnerabilities put millions of IoT devices at risk, so patch now
Internet Security

These new vulnerabilities put millions of IoT devices at risk, so patch now

April 13, 2021
Apple looking to close the gap between web and app privacy
Internet Security

Who do I pay to get the ‘phone’ removed from my iPhone?

April 13, 2021
Next Post
Goldman Sachs Must Amend AI Bias to Regain Apple Card User Trust

Goldman Sachs Must Amend AI Bias to Regain Apple Card User Trust

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Plasticity in Deep Learning: Dynamic Adaptations for AI Self-Driving Cars

Plasticity in Deep Learning: Dynamic Adaptations for AI Self-Driving Cars

January 6, 2019
Microsoft, Google Use Artificial Intelligence to Fight Hackers

Microsoft, Google Use Artificial Intelligence to Fight Hackers

January 6, 2019

Categories

  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Big Data
  • Blockchain
  • Crypto News
  • Data Science
  • Digital Marketing
  • Internet Privacy
  • Internet Security
  • Learn to Code
  • Machine Learning
  • Marketing Technology
  • Neural Networks
  • Technology Companies

Don't miss it

Five Top Quality APIs
Learn to Code

Five Top Quality APIs

April 14, 2021
Cybersecurity: Victims are spotting cyber attacks much more quickly – but there’s a catch
Internet Security

Cybersecurity: Victims are spotting cyber attacks much more quickly – but there’s a catch

April 14, 2021
Detecting the “Next” SolarWinds-Style Cyber Attack
Internet Privacy

Detecting the “Next” SolarWinds-Style Cyber Attack

April 14, 2021
Weekly NFT roundup March 23-29: Circle, Klaytn, and more
Blockchain

Weekly NFT roundup April 7–13: Christie’s, Triller, and more

April 14, 2021
Machine learning can help keep the global supply chain moving
Machine Learning

Machine learning can help keep the global supply chain moving

April 14, 2021
Why I Think That Avengers: Age of Ultron is One of the Best Sci-Fi Movies About A.I | by Brighton Nkomo | Apr, 2021
Neural Networks

Why I Think That Avengers: Age of Ultron is One of the Best Sci-Fi Movies About A.I | by Brighton Nkomo | Apr, 2021

April 14, 2021
NikolaNews

NikolaNews.com is an online News Portal which aims to share news about blockchain, AI, Big Data, and Data Privacy and more!

What’s New Here?

  • Five Top Quality APIs April 14, 2021
  • Cybersecurity: Victims are spotting cyber attacks much more quickly – but there’s a catch April 14, 2021
  • Detecting the “Next” SolarWinds-Style Cyber Attack April 14, 2021
  • Weekly NFT roundup April 7–13: Christie’s, Triller, and more April 14, 2021

Subscribe to get more!

© 2019 NikolaNews.com - Global Tech Updates

No Result
View All Result
  • AI Development
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Machine Learning
    • Neural Networks
    • Learn to Code
  • Data
    • Blockchain
    • Big Data
    • Data Science
  • IT Security
    • Internet Privacy
    • Internet Security
  • Marketing
    • Digital Marketing
    • Marketing Technology
  • Technology Companies
  • Crypto News

© 2019 NikolaNews.com - Global Tech Updates